SRB_2021_DHIPIE-EL_v01_M
Inclusive Early Childhood Education and Care Impact Evaluation 2021 - Endline Survey
DHIPIE-EL 2021
Name | Country code |
---|---|
Serbia | SRB |
Other Household Survey [hh/oth]
The Inclusive Early Childhood Education and Care Impact Evaluation evaluated the virtual parenting skills workshops in Serbia for parents of children aged 2-6. The study’s goal was to examine the extent to which parenting workshops and communications improve parenting behaviors, attitudes, and knowledge to promote early childhood development, and to assess, to what extent, those changes were reflected in parent-reported child outcomes. The evaluation used a randomized control trial (RCT) to test the impact of virtual parenting workshops on parenting behaviors and early childhood development. The study also tested whether or not father participation in parental training improved fathers’ behaviors, attitudes, and knowledge to promote early childhood development, and to what extent those changes were reflected in parent-reported child outcomes. The program was delivered by preschool teachers who work at the local preschool institutions. The program was adapted from face-to-face meetings to virtual meeting group discussions, SMS messages, audio messages, calls, and a guide and complementary materials to have at home. The workshops spanned 8 weeks, and covered topics of play, parentings stimulation, family environment and father involvement among others. The sampling frame was the universe of families enrolled in the program in the target municipalities where this program was being implemented. From this universe we randomly assigned families in three groups: Treatment 1 (T1): Parenting virtual workshops for main caregiver (T1), Parenting virtual workshops for female and male caregiver (T2) and control groups who were placed on a waitlist and were prioritized to receive the workshops after endline data was collected. The evaluation included 1,431 families in total in a two-phase delivery. The first phase started the implementation in December 2020 and the second phase started the program in March 2021. Baseline data was collected online through an enrollment form that families filled out to participate in the program (this data can be found here https://microdata.worldbank.org/index.php/catalog/6197 ). The first phase started enrollment in October 2020 and the second phase started in February 2021.
Endline data was collected for both phases via phone interview from August through October 2021. The instrument measured parental practices, parental stress, parental beliefs and attitudes, and child development as reported by the caregiver.
Sample survey data [ssd]
Households with children between 2 and 6 years of age
Edited, anonymized version for public distribution
2022-03-22
The study took place in four of the five regions of Serbia (Vojvodina, Belgrade region, Region of South-East Serbia and Region of Sumadia and West Serbia). Participating preschool institutions were located in 13 districts and 21 municipalities (Bac, Becej, Kragujevac, Niš, Odžaci, Pancevo, Požarevac, Sjenica, Smederevska Palanka, Svrljig, Valjevo, Vranje and Žabalj, Apatin, Golubac, Lazarevac, Majdanpek, Palilula, Smederevo, Velika Plana and Vlasotince). Within each targeted municipality, one public preschool institution was invited to participate, and those preschool institutions recruited families with children ages 2-6 within their catchment areas through brochures, pamphlets, and social media.
Name | Affiliation |
---|---|
Ana Maria Munoz Boudet | World Bank |
Pedro Carneiro | UCL |
Katia Marina Herrera Sosa | World Bank |
Julie Perng | Federal Retirement Thrift Investment Board |
Tamara Arnold Urzua | World Bank |
Lara Lebedinski | World Bank |
Name | Abbreviation | Role |
---|---|---|
Strategic Impact Evaluation Fund | SIEF | Funding |
Umbrella Facility for Gender Equality | UFGE | Funding |
Preschool institutions conducted recruitment of families with children ages 2-6 of their catchment areas by inviting them to participate in the parenting program. Interested families filled out an online enrollment form, providing information about their location, education level, main source of income, connectivity, number and age of children, preschool enrollment and language.
The sampling frame is the universe of families enrolled to participate in the parenting program. From this group, families were randomly assigned into the two treatment and the control arms based on strata (developed based on income source being salary, having a higher education, and preferred language being Serbian); the unit of randomization was at the individual level.
After randomization was done, the research team created 6 to 10 parenting groups within each preschool based on language and physical location/preschool that the parents are closest to.
The program was rolled out in two phases. For the first phase the program implementation recruited a total of 1070 eligible families (270 treatment 1, 270 treatment 2 and 530 control). To have the expected total sample of 1440, additional 361 families (95 treatment 1, 110 treatment 2 and 156 control) were recruited during second phase in February 2021. The final sample is 1431 families (365 treatment 1, 380 treatment 2 and 686 control). For a little under 40% of the sample, secondary (male) caregivers were interviewed with a shortened version of the survey.
Among the parents who initially applied to the program, 62.2 percent were interviewed at endline.
The baseline sampling procedure was aligned to what was proposed in the research proposal including 1431 families.
Endlinde data was collected for 890 families. There are two main reasons why parents were not interviewed. (1) parents who wanted to (or did) participate in the program but did not give consent to be called for the endline survey (whether explicitly or because they could not be contacted); and (2) parents who gave consent to be contacted for the endline survey but eventually refused to participate when they were contacted for the interview. The not interviewed group 1 included 13 percent of the initial sample (187 families). The not interviewed group 2 included 24.8 percent (354 families) of the initial sample.
Among the parents who initially applied to the program, 62.2 percent were interviewed at endline.
The endline data collection questionnaire collects information on parental practices, parental stress, parental beliefs and attitudes, and child development as reported by the caregiver, household characteristics. Parental practices were measured using an adapted version of Home Observation Measurement of the Environment- Short Form (HOME-SF), the Family Care Indicators (FCI) and the Child Discipline Module of the MICS6 survey. Child development of children 2 to 6 years old, as reported by the main caregiver, was assessed combining the Early Childhood Development Index (ECDI 2030) and the Anchor Items for Measurement of Early Childhood Development Caregiver Report of (AIM-ECD-CR).
A shorter version of this questionnaire was also applied to a subsample of the male caregiver of the children.
The questionnaire is provided for download under the Downloads section.
Start | End | Cycle |
---|---|---|
2021-08-25 | 2021-11-27 | Endline |
The endline data collection was done over the phone by IPSOS between August and October 2021. Of the 1,431 that participated in the evaluation, only 1,244 families provided consent to be surveyed at endline. The main caregiver of the 2-6 year old child that was the focus of the program answered a questionnaire about parental practices, parental stress, parental beliefs and attitudes, and child development.
354 parents who gave consent to be contacted for the endline survey, eventually refused to participate when they were contacted for the interview.
Name |
---|
Human Development Network (HDN) |
Example:
Use of the dataset must be acknowledged using a citation which would include: - the Identification of the Primary Investigator - the title of the survey (including country, acronym and year of implementation) - the survey reference number - the source and date of download. Example: Carneiro P., Herrera Sosa K., Munoz Boudet A.M., World Bank. Inclusive Early Childhood Education and Care Impact Evaluation 2020, Endline Survey. Ref. SRB_2021_DHIPIE-EL_v01_M. Dataset downloaded from [URL] on [date].
The user of the data acknowledges that the original collector of the data, the authorized distributor of the data, and the relevant funding agency bear no responsibility for use of the data or for interpretations or inferences based upon such uses.
DDI_SRB_2021_DHIPIE-EL_v01_M_WB
Name | Abbreviation | Affiliation | Role |
---|---|---|---|
Development Data Group | DECDG | World Bank | Documentation of the study |
2024-03-14
Version 01 (2024-03-14)