IHSN Survey Catalog
  • Home
  • Microdata Catalog
  • Citations
  • Login
    Login
    Home / Central Data Catalog / EST_2021_ECMIE_V01_M
central

Enhanced Care Management Impact Evaluation 2021 Update

Estonia, 2021
Get Microdata
Reference ID
EST_2021_ECMIE_v01_M
Producer(s)
Dan Rogger, Kevin Croke, Benjamin Danels
Metadata
Documentation in PDF DDI/XML JSON
Study website
Created on
Feb 19, 2025
Last modified
Feb 19, 2025
Page views
576
Downloads
38
  • Study Description
  • Data Dictionary
  • Downloads
  • Get Microdata
  • Identification
  • Version
  • Scope
  • Coverage
  • Producers and sponsors
  • Sampling
  • Survey instrument
  • Data collection
  • Access policy
  • Depositor information
  • Distributor information
  • Data Access
  • Disclaimer and copyrights
  • Contacts
  • Metadata production
  • Identification

    Survey ID number

    EST_2021_ECMIE_v01_M

    Title

    Enhanced Care Management Impact Evaluation 2021 Update

    Abbreviation or Acronym

    ECMIE 2021

    Country
    Name Country code
    Estonia EST
    Study type

    Administrative Records, Health (ad/hea]

    Series Information

    This is the 2021 summary data for this impact evaluation. The 2019 data can be accessed by staff on the Microdata Library here: https://microdatalib.worldbank.org/index.php/catalog/12005.

    Abstract

    The Enhanced Care Management (ECM) intervention consists of training and coaching doctors and their teams to develop holistic care and pro-active outreach plans for chronically ill patients or those vulnerable to developing chronically illnesses. The core goal of ECM is to improve the quality of care provided to complex patients, including by increasing the use of preventive care, better coordinating care across health system levels, and increasing patient involvement in care. These elements can improve patient health and quality of life, and may reduce the need for curative medical services—for example, by supporting patients with diabetes to improve their diet and increase their level of fitness to limit further deterioration in their health.

    ECM practices include improved tracking of tests and referrals, follow-up after hospital discharges, tracking medication adherence, monitoring between clinic visits, and focusing on achieving clinical quality. It includes four elements: identifying high-risk patients through risk stratification, developing care management plans by the primary care physician, proactively linking care providers together, and developing a team approach with patients and their caregivers.

    Kind of Data

    Aggregate data [agg]

    Unit of Analysis

    Enhanced Care Management provider

    Version

    Version Description

    v01: Edited, anonymous dataset for official use

    Version Date

    2021-12-15

    Version Notes

    This version of the data includes the initial program uptake summary. The unit of analysis is the ECM provider. There are a total of 97 providers included in ECM out of 800 providers in the Estonia Health Insurance Fund network. This dataset includes the summary for these 97 providers on ECM take up indicators such as care plans, patient invitations and patient consultations.

    Scope

    Notes

    The scope of this study includes the following:

    Random assignment of clinics into ECM and non-ECM clinics, Quality Bonus Scheme score, Management score, and Coarsened Exact Matching (CEM) stratification

    Coverage

    Geographic Coverage

    97 providers in the Estonia Health Insurance Fund and 2,389 patients spread across Estonia

    Universe

    Clinics and providers in Estonia registered with the Estonia Health Insurance Fund (EHIF)

    Producers and sponsors

    Primary investigators
    Name Affiliation
    Dan Rogger The World Bank Group
    Kevin Croke Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
    Benjamin Danels Georgetown University
    Producers
    Name Affiliation Role
    Jekaternia Steinmiller Estonia Health Insurance Fund Implementing partner
    Funding Agency/Sponsor
    Name Abbreviation
    Strategic Impact Evaluation Fund SIEF

    Sampling

    Sampling Procedure

    Sampling of the Enhanced Care Management (ECM) intervention is done in two stages: 1. The first stage of sampling was done at the clinic level. The randomization was done by making performance blocks of management and Quality Bonus Scheme (QBS) score and, selecting 1/4th of clinics randomly from each block into ECM. Initially there were 93 clinics and 144 providers selected into ECM. 2. The second stage of sampling was done at the patient level. From each selected provider, 25 patients were selected into ECM using stratified random sampling.

    This data submission consists of summary indicators for ECM activities. The most recent activity in ECM was making care plans of patients selected into ECM. The patient selection into ECM was conducted between June-September 2021 and 2,389 patients were randomly selected into ECM. Since then, the main ECM activities have been:

    • The providers and coordinators beginning outreach to invite patients to enroll in ECM.
    • The providers recording refusal to join by patients, in the claims data.
    • The providers and coordinators making care plans for patients.
    Deviations from the Sample Design

    Any deviations from the sample design are due to provider dropout. 48 providers refused to participate in the program which reduced the number of providers in ECM. The patient refusal to join the program is recorded in the billing data.

    Survey instrument

    Methodology notes
    1. All the de-identification was done compliant with Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA)
    2. All the identifiers are removed or de-identified in the dataset

    Data collection

    Dates of Data Collection
    Start End Cycle
    2021-01-01 2021-01-11 Annual
    Frequency of Data Collection

    Annual

    Mode of data collection
    • Other [oth]
    Data Collectors
    Name
    Estonia Health Insurance Fund
    Data Collection Notes

    The Estonia Health Insurance Fund (EHIF) billing data includes every health interaction of Estonian citizens. In summary, we have electronic medical and billing records spread over eight health care types - primary health care, day care, outpatient care, outpatient nursing care, outpatient rehabilitation care, inpatient care, inpatient nursing care, and inpatient rehabilitation care from 2009 until 2019.

    Access policy

    Location of Data Collection

    World Bank Microdata Library

    URL for Location of Data Collection

    https://microdata.worldbank.org

    Depositor information

    Depositor
    Name Affiliation
    Meyhar Mohammed LNU The World Bank Group
    Date of Deposit

    2021-12-15

    Distributor information

    Distributor
    Organization name Affiliation
    Microdata Library World Bank

    Data Access

    Access authority
    Name Affiliation URL Email
    Strategic Impact Evaluation Fund The World Bank Group https://www.worldbank.org/en/programs/sief-trust-fund siefimpact@worldbank.org
    Daniel Rogger The World Bank Group drogger@worldbank.org
    Meyhar Mohammed The World Bank Group mlnu15@worldbank.org
    Katre Vaarsi The World Bank Group kvaeaersi@worldbank.org
    Access conditions

    Official Access

    Citation requirements

    Use of the dataset must be acknowledged using a citation which would include:

    • the Identification of the Primary Investigator
    • the title of the survey (including country, acronym and year of implementation)
    • the survey reference number
    • the source and date of download

    Example:
    World Bank Group. Estonia - Enhanced Care Management Impact Evaluation 2021 Update. Ref: EST_2021_ECMIE_v01_M. Dataset downloaded from [URL] on [date].

    Disclaimer and copyrights

    Disclaimer

    The user of the data acknowledges that the original collector of the data, the authorized distributor of the data, and the relevant funding agency bear no responsibility for use of the data or for interpretations or inferences based upon such uses.

    Contacts

    Contacts
    Name Affiliation Email
    Strategic Impact Evaluation Fund The World Bank Group siefimpact@worldbank.org
    Daniel Rogger The World Bank Group drogger@worldbank.org
    Meyhar Mohammed The World Bank Group mlnu15@worldbank.org
    Katre Vaarsi The World Bank Group kvaeaersi@worldbank.org

    Metadata production

    DDI Document ID

    DDI_EST_2021_ECMIE_v01_M_WB

    Producers
    Name Abbreviation Affiliation Role
    Development Economics Data Group DECDG The World Bank Group Documentation of the study
    Date of Metadata Production

    2023-07-26

    Metadata version

    DDI Document version

    Version 01 (July 2023)

    Version date

    2021-01-19

    Back to Catalog
    IHSN Survey Catalog

    © IHSN Survey Catalog, All Rights Reserved.